My friend Ann Ferren told me this story about a science faculty member who was continually frustrated with how badly his students wrote lab reports. Each week a new crop of poor writing would be handed in, and he would spend way too much time writing his comments in red ink all over them. But the writing failed to improve.
Inspiration struck.
He then tried the following:
a) He told them he really cared about their writing
b) He distributed the criteria he was using in grading (this is sometimes called a 'rubric')
c) He told them that as soon as their writing earned an "A", they would no longer be required to turn in lab reports.
The results were wonderful.
One quarter of the students got "A"s on their first report. Another quarter of his students got an "A" on their second report. Pretty soon he was saving time and only coaching students who genuinely had problems with writing.
PS. Quite a few students continued to write the reports without handing them in; by writing a genuinely good report, those students has seen how writing a good report could help them learn from the lab work.
Grazing - a personal blog from Steve Ehrmann
Steve Ehrmann is an author, speaker, and consultant.
Showing posts with label Classroom Assessment Techniques. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Classroom Assessment Techniques. Show all posts
Wednesday, October 30, 2013
Sunday, September 22, 2013
What Kinds of Teaching Improvement are Most Important?
Which kinds of teaching improvement are most important for the Teaching & Learning Collaborative (TLC) to support over the coming years? To advance that discussion, I'll suggest three interdependent goals now, and a couple more in an upcoming post:
1. Support learning-centered teaching. There's a lovely cartoon showing a boy with his dog. The boy is talking to his friend, and boasting that he's taught Spot to whistle. The friend responds dubiously, "I don't hear him whistling." The first boy retorts, "I said I taught him. I didn't say he learned it!"
I hope we can help an increasing number of faculty teach in a way that's guided by the actual learning that occurs in their academic programs. Faculty who understand teaching in this way ('the learning paradigm') believe that virtually every student is capable of excellence, if teaching can guide and stimulate them appropriately. Because it's not obvious at the start what needs to be done to help students achieve excellence, there's a certain amount of trial and error every term - the instructor tries something and, if it works for some students, do more of it. If it doesn't work for some students, try something else.
I hope we can help an increasing number of faculty teach in a way that's guided by the actual learning that occurs in their academic programs. Faculty who understand teaching in this way ('the learning paradigm') believe that virtually every student is capable of excellence, if teaching can guide and stimulate them appropriately. Because it's not obvious at the start what needs to be done to help students achieve excellence, there's a certain amount of trial and error every term - the instructor tries something and, if it works for some students, do more of it. If it doesn't work for some students, try something else.
- The alternative view of teaching, sometimes called the 'instruction paradigm', is reflected in the comments of Spot's owner. Teaching and learning are independent activities. If you organize and present the content clearly, then you've taught it. If the students learn it, that's entirely to their credit. If they don't, that's on them, too.
2. Support evidence-guided teaching. Because teaching needs to be guided by actual learning, then the faculty need to gather evidence of how the learning process is going.
More easily said than done. For example, if the faculty member assesses the wrong thing -- testing whether the student can remember an expert's analysis when the real goal is to help students learn to analyze for themselves -- then scores or grades will mislead both the instructor and the student.
More easily said than done. For example, if the faculty member assesses the wrong thing -- testing whether the student can remember an expert's analysis when the real goal is to help students learn to analyze for themselves -- then scores or grades will mislead both the instructor and the student.
Testing what students have learned is necessary but not sufficient. Analogy: people learning to bat in the game of baseball. Measuring their batting average, no matter how precisely, won't help them learn to hit better. A very different kind of feedback is needed for that, e.g., slow motion video of how they swing at a pitch. Faculty need to learn both how to provide two very different kinds of feedback for themselves and for their students: what the student has learned and how the student is learning. Few faculty have received any training in the many ways in which these things have been done. We can help with that.
3. Support faculty collaboration to improve learning. I mean "faculty collaboration" in two different ways.
The first is illustrated by a research finding about composition courses. In many evaluations of learning in composition, students are asked to write a composition at the beginning of the term and a second composition on a similar topic at the end of the term. External graders then assess each paper without knowing when it was written. The papers written at the beginning and at the end of the writing course often get similar grades. This does not mean that the students learned nothing about writing: over two or more courses, the essays do measurably improve. The important lesson: the kinds of capabilities useful in life are often so complex and personal that one course often can't do not enough to create improvements large enough to measure. As a senior once told me about something he'd learned, "I don't think I could have learned how to think that way in any one course, but, over the years, it gradually sank in."
That's why capstone courses and major projects in upper division courses can be so important: as sources of insight for faculty teaching lower division courses on where they're succeeding and where they need to improve.
The second important kind of collaboration is between faculty and others, e.g., instructional designers, assessment experts, publishers and other materials developers outside the university. I'll choose just one example: instructional designers in a number of departments at GW are currently testing ePortfolio products that faculty can use, individually and as teams, to gather and analyze evidence of student learning.
So those are my first three suggestions for where we should focus our support: learning-centered teaching, evidence-guided teaching, and collaboration to improve learning.
So those are my first three suggestions for where we should focus our support: learning-centered teaching, evidence-guided teaching, and collaboration to improve learning.
Over the next 5-10 years, what (additional) kinds of teaching improvement do you think that units like TLC should support?
Sunday, March 24, 2013
Should Students Discuss How to Learn and Study?
As I look back on my own days in college, I'm embarrassed to remember how many things I believed about learning that got in my way!
For example, in my freshman advanced calculus course, I assumed that, so long as I could follow what the professor said in class, I was doing fine.
And I never considered going to a prof's office hours. If I wasn't doing all that well in the course, i was hoping he wouldn't notice until I could somehow catch up!
And, really, I didn't think much about learning (that is, improving what I could do, what I could see, and who I was). Instead, I was more focused on grades and credits. And even more on my extra-curricular activities (writing a book, serving in student government), where I could see that I was getting things done, and that I was getting stronger.
I wonder how much more I would have learned if I'd had different beliefs about learning and how to learn... (Yes, I did go on to get my MIT Ph.D. but I don't seem to remember much from my undergraduate courses.)
That's why I've been assembling a list of common student beliefs about learning. And I turned some of them into a (first draft) questionnaire that an instructor might administer to students at the start of the semester:
http://go.gwu.edu/beliefs
After students answer all the questions, the instructor would start with item #1 and ask for a show of hands (or use clickers and ask them to click). Who strongly agrees or agrees? Who strongly disagrees or disagrees?
If the class is split on a belief, students would gather in small groups, each of which has at least one student on each side of the question. They'd each summarize their own reasoning or experience. Then poll the students again to see if there's been any change in their opinions.
Go through the cycle again for each item on the form. (My first draft has 10 questions, but I can imagine that a faculty member might prune it to, say, 5 items before giving it to students.)
If the course features online discussion, the instructor might administer the questions online and post the results. Each week the students might discuss one or two of the items online where there had been significant disagreement.
What do you think?
For example, in my freshman advanced calculus course, I assumed that, so long as I could follow what the professor said in class, I was doing fine.
And I never considered going to a prof's office hours. If I wasn't doing all that well in the course, i was hoping he wouldn't notice until I could somehow catch up!
And, really, I didn't think much about learning (that is, improving what I could do, what I could see, and who I was). Instead, I was more focused on grades and credits. And even more on my extra-curricular activities (writing a book, serving in student government), where I could see that I was getting things done, and that I was getting stronger.
I wonder how much more I would have learned if I'd had different beliefs about learning and how to learn... (Yes, I did go on to get my MIT Ph.D. but I don't seem to remember much from my undergraduate courses.)
That's why I've been assembling a list of common student beliefs about learning. And I turned some of them into a (first draft) questionnaire that an instructor might administer to students at the start of the semester:
http://go.gwu.edu/beliefs
After students answer all the questions, the instructor would start with item #1 and ask for a show of hands (or use clickers and ask them to click). Who strongly agrees or agrees? Who strongly disagrees or disagrees?
If the class is split on a belief, students would gather in small groups, each of which has at least one student on each side of the question. They'd each summarize their own reasoning or experience. Then poll the students again to see if there's been any change in their opinions.
Go through the cycle again for each item on the form. (My first draft has 10 questions, but I can imagine that a faculty member might prune it to, say, 5 items before giving it to students.)
If the course features online discussion, the instructor might administer the questions online and post the results. Each week the students might discuss one or two of the items online where there had been significant disagreement.
What do you think?
- Does it make sense to talk with your students about learning and studying at the start of the semester?
- I know some instructors just tell students how to study; what do you think of asking them to debate the questions among themselves?
- If you like the general idea, what do you think of these particular questions?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)