Mike Moore, Prof. of Economics and International Affairs at George Washington University, has problems with asthma. So this past semester he taught two courses to GW students (mostly) from Santa Fe, New Mexico. He did it by prerecording his lectures, posting them on YouTube, conducting live online office hours using Blackboard Collaborate, and visiting GW monthly for 90 minute face-to-face sessions with his students.
Mike didn't jump from traditional teaching to this strategy in one huge leap.
Some years ago, he taped some lectures on background material so that students could study and review them as often as they liked. A few years after that, he tried GW LectureCapture - a system for automatically recording all class sessions and making recordings available only to students in that class. He'd worried that students wouldn't come to class if recordings were available but (as with every other faculty member I've found who's used a system like this), his worries were unfounded. Attendance was unaffected.
Recently, he realized it would be better for him to spend some time in New Mexico and got permission from Mike Brown, his Dean, to teach a hybrid course - a mix of online and face-to-face instruction.
Early on he decided to use YouTube so that anyone could see his lectures. He then took a look at examples of classes on YouTube. Some had pretty poor audio or picture quality; he knew he wanted to do better.
To create the lectures with HD quality, he pointed the camera of an iPad at a whiteboard. He was no longer limited to the normal time constraints of a campus class. So he created about 75 small lectures, averaging 15 minutes in length. Some was material that would normally have been given in class but he also added additional material. This was the big investment. "I hope I can do this again because creating those videos took maybe 400 hours of work," he commented: if he teaches the course again, he can reuse some or all of those videos. He likes this approach to creating chunks of video because he can edit them if he likes. That removes the pressure to do each one perfectly the first time.
Even though the material is abstruse, the videos are popular. His videos had already been viewed over 65,000 times and over 60% of those views were requested from outside the United States.
Mike also created some interactive homework online, using Blackboard: multiple choice questions that provide hints to students if their initial answer is incorrect. There are also four online quizzes each semester: multiple choice and only a small fraction of the class grade.
For his live online office with Blackboard Collaborate, Mike uses a tablet so that he can draw. Those sessions are recorded so students can take part live and/or review them later.
Monthly Mike comes to GW for live, 90-minute sessions with students, a mix of lecture and discussion The midterm and final are administered during these sessions as well. After the midterm he polled students and about 2/3 responded. "They love it, the structure, the delivery. The most telling set of comments is that they
loved being able to listen to the lecture whenever they want, pause, replay to
get the details." One student could take the course despite the fact that he had to spend a month in Malawi during the semester. I interviewed Mike before the final was administered but he was already pleased with the quality of the students' work. I've heard since that his end-of-course student feedback scores were among the best he's ever received.
I take particular note on that last point. Student feedback is not proof of superior learning. But, if the learning itself could be assessed, it would not be surprising to find that this design could be both more accessible to both faculty and students (they don't need to all be in the same place, and there's less need to coordinate schedules) and also produce superior learning outcomes. There's a long history in education of using technology in ways that can produce gains in quality and access simultaneously, going back to printed books as a way of both increasing an author's audience and enable readers to study the author's words more closely than would be possible in an auditorium.
if you'd like to learn more, Mike's email is mom@gwu.edu.
Grazing - a personal blog from Steve Ehrmann
Steve Ehrmann is an author, speaker, and consultant.
Showing posts with label hybrid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hybrid. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 21, 2014
Sunday, April 6, 2014
Improving teaching & learning for non-native speakers of English
Like many other universities, George Washington is attracting more students, faculty and teaching assistants with different native languages. I'm not an expert in either second language learning or teaching international students. What follows are the speculations by a generalist. If you have better information and contrasting ideas, I hope you'll post them below. In the meantime, here's how things look to me.
Faculty-student interaction, rapid feed back, and student teamwork can each improve learning, but only to the extent that those people can easily understand one another, which includes being able to think quickly in English. It's not surprising that a study at the New Jersey Institute of Technology (NJIT) in the 1980s found that non-native speakers of English got lower grades, on average, than native speakers. I'll get back to that study in a moment.
I have a suggestion for how we can improve education for all our students, but especially for non-native speakers of English.
Faculty-student interaction, rapid feed back, and student teamwork can each improve learning, but only to the extent that those people can easily understand one another, which includes being able to think quickly in English. It's not surprising that a study at the New Jersey Institute of Technology (NJIT) in the 1980s found that non-native speakers of English got lower grades, on average, than native speakers. I'll get back to that study in a moment.
I have a suggestion for how we can improve education for all our students, but especially for non-native speakers of English.
Hypothesis: learning can improve if a campus makes more, better use of vigorous, critical, online, written discussion (e.g., dialogue using tools such as email, threaded discussions in Blackboard, and more specialized tools such as VoiceThread).
Why might that be true?
Remember that NJIT finding that non-native speakers were getting worse grades in campus courses? Let me tell you more about that.
in the mid 1980s, NJIT had pioneered online courses. In one study, Prof. Roxanne Hiltz compared the grades of native English speakers with non-native speakers across many courses (Hiltz, 1988). As I mentioned earlier, the native speakers got better grades in their NJIT courses. One might imagine many reasons for that. Perhaps their high schools were inferior to ours, for example.
But Hiltz also compared the grades of native and non-native speakers taking wholly online courses. No significant difference in the academic performance of native- versus non-native speakers of English (nor do students in online courses do worse than students taking campus courses).
Hiltz concluded that, in the campus classroom, non-native speakers find it difficult to listen, think and speak fast enough in English to fully participate in learning.
In contrast, in written online exchange, with plenty of time to interpret and respond, non-native speakers were able to participate fully, demonstrating their talent, preparation, and motivation.
The benefits of online discussion for non-native speakers aren't limited to learning the substance of the course.
Karen Smith, then at the University of Arizona, studied non-native speakers of Spanish: American students who were taking Spanish IV. (Smith, 1990)
In one section of Spanish, the students used a language laboratory, listening to Spanish on headsets and practicing pronunciation.
In another section, students were assigned to converse online in written Spanish. They were graded only on their fluency in expressing complex thoughts, not on syntax or spelling. And they had the option of initiating their own discussions, and of conducting some of the discussions in private. (These students also were assigned to work in the language lab but for less time each week, to make time for their work online.)
I visited that section in mid-semester. The students loved that they could converse in Spanish about issues they cared about. In one online discussion for example, a number of students were communing with a classmate who was feeling depressed. In another discussion they discussed a film that had been shown in class, while in another they planned a class party, all in Spanish. Students liked the fact that, online, they had time to interpret and consider what they were 'hearing' and then to plan how to reply. And, for these discussions, they were not being graded on their spelling or grammar.
Here's the surprise. At the end of the semester, the two groups of students were each given an oral examination. And the students who'd been practicing oral Spanish in the language laboratory lost. The students who, instead, had been conversing asynchronously in written Spanish were better able to think in Spanish. So now, in real-time face-to-face conversation, they found it easier to speak fluently (and grammatically).
This suggests that online discussion can prepare our non-native speakers to listen and speak face-to-face in the languages of their disciplines as well.
Adding online discussion to campus courses can help all students learn, not just the non-native speakers of English.
Some years ago, I was talking with a young professor of philosophy at another institution. "I can't talk philosophy with an undergraduate," he remarked. "They just don't know the subject well enough." He paused and then continued, "Ah, but email! When we're conversing by email, we can have quite a satisfactory discussion. The student has enough time to interpret what I've said and to plan their response."
Think about it: in every discipline, students are learning to think in, and speak, a new language: the language of philosophy, or physiology, or law. It's easier for novices to learn to think, speak and see in a new field if first they can do it at a thoughtful pace. (In a future post, I'll suggest a strategy for fostering more critical, searching online discussions.)
Bottom line: By incorporating the right kind of vigorous, critical online discussion in our campus courses, we can improve learning for non-native speakers of English, for others with issues listening or speaking in a group talking at classroom speed, and for all our other students too.
Bottom line: By incorporating the right kind of vigorous, critical online discussion in our campus courses, we can improve learning for non-native speakers of English, for others with issues listening or speaking in a group talking at classroom speed, and for all our other students too.
If you're interested in learning more about how to use technology in these ways in your own courses at GW, contact our Instructional Technology Laboratory in the basement of Gelman Library about the technology and our Teaching & Learning Collaborative (our teaching center) to talk about how to organize and moderate such discussions. If you'd like to talk with someone from the TLC about these issues, you can use this form to arrange for a meeting.
REFERENCES
1988 Hiltz, Starr
Roxanne, "Learning in a Virtual Classroom" (Executive Summary and two
volumes), Research Report #25 and 26, Computerized Conferencing and
Communications Center, New Jersey Institute of Technology.
1990 Smith, Karen L.
Collaborative and Interactive Writing for Increasing Communication Skills, Hispania, LXXIII:1, pp. 77-87.
Sunday, July 3, 2011
How can hybrid (and online) courses be better than campus courses?
Many institutions want to offer hybrid and online courses in order to improve the economic bottom line: to make better use of expensive campus space, increase enrollments, and allow working students to carry bigger loads and graduate sooner. Those aren't bad motivations.
But it's also the case that, in selected ways, good hybrid and online courses can be better than campus courses that rely mainly on lecturing, textbooks, and students doing homework alone.
By "hybrid" I mean courses where the instructor allocates more time to work outside the classroom by shrinking the time that students and the instructor spend on the classroom. The goal: improve learning while not increasing total time spent on the course by students or faculty.
Here are a few ways in which such hybrids and online courses can be superior to traditional classroom formats (especially when classes have more than, say, 30 students). Can you suggest others?
Large campus-bound courses teach one message to all students, a message which may motivate some students more than others, at a pace that may be right for some students, too fast for others, too slow for still others. In contrast, courses that do more (or all) of their work online enable faculty to offer more than one version of lectures, assignments, and even tests. The goal: to excite and engage a larger fraction of all students by giving them challenges that mean something at a pace they can maintain. For example, a class in biology might offer three versions of some lectures or assignments: one version pitched more toward future health care practitioners, another for future engineers, and another for future scientists. (These different versions need not be created by one faculty member all at once. Faculty might split the effort, or a single faculty member might develop different versions over a period of years.)
Just in time learning: In order to motivate students to come to the class sessions prepared, use online quizzes, discussions, or assignments that are due just before class. Gathering data just before class can also help instructors create classroom activities that respond to what students have learned, or what they still misunderstand.
More thoughtful pace of discussion: Traditional classrooms, especially when classes are large, offer few students a chance to answer questions, or discuss issues. Online discussion (e.g.,, threaded discussions on Blackboard) give all students a chance to talk, with each other, and with faculty. The time-delay gives students a chance to think about what’s been said, and to think about what they want to say. Many faculty have observed that students indeed become more thoughtful when the pace of conversation slows down, and there’s no danger of being interrupted.
Expand the visual dimension: Traditional classroom formats are dominated by words. But the visual dimension (still, motion) is potentially crucial in many disciplines (e.g., art history, health care, sociology, engineering, ...). For students to develop an educated, intuitive understanding of visual materials, students must be able to (a) call up one or more visual artifacts, (b) discuss those artifact(s) with other students and the instructor while pointing to elements of the visual materials ("Notice the contrast between this and that."). Student discussion of visual materials can often be done more easily and inexpensively online (e.g., using Elluminate, Adobe Connect, Wimba, or other real-time conferencing systems or created narrated presentations using software such as PowerPoint or Prezi.)
Open the conversation: Traditional classrooms have a closed door: discussion is limited to the faculty member and students registered in the class. Online discussions are more easily expanded to include significant others outside that group: outside experts, students who differ from those in class, members of the public. For an extreme example of this, see my previous post.
Expand the variety of students and classwork settings: Online and some hybrid formats enable a program to recruit a student body of unusual talents and diversity. For example, some hybrid programs (often masters programs) combine substantial online work with periods when students and faculty gather in one instructional setting (not always on the home campus). For example, Prof. Maida Withers, at George Washington University, leads a new blended (hybrid) master's program in dance. Students applying for admission were required to have identified their settings near their residences where they could practice, choreograph, and present their dances.
Expand the expertise used in offering the program: the more interaction is online, the easier and more natural it is to use instructors and guest experts selected for their fit to the program. Guest experts can speak with a classroom from a distance, but it's even more natural if everyone is online, as natural as a conference call. Some instructors use a 20 minute guest presentation or discussion, involving a different specialist, every week. Assign a reading, and then give students an opportunity to interview the author online.
Increase the specialization of the program: Put all these pieces together: it's possible to offer incredible programs that can be be unusually specialized in order to attract (distant) highly motivated students-- interdisciplinary degrees in HMO management, sustainable recreation, 21st century literature and culture, ... Such programs might be targeted at small, high-paying, recently created job markets. Such programs could be taught by a combination of local faculty and top experts from around the world. The program design would ideally be hybrid: a mix of online education with gatherings of faculty and students at appropriate sites for intense work and coaching.
But it's also the case that, in selected ways, good hybrid and online courses can be better than campus courses that rely mainly on lecturing, textbooks, and students doing homework alone.
By "hybrid" I mean courses where the instructor allocates more time to work outside the classroom by shrinking the time that students and the instructor spend on the classroom. The goal: improve learning while not increasing total time spent on the course by students or faculty.
Here are a few ways in which such hybrids and online courses can be superior to traditional classroom formats (especially when classes have more than, say, 30 students). Can you suggest others?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)