Grazing - a personal blog from Steve Ehrmann

Steve Ehrmann is an author, speaker, and consultant.
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Friday, October 18, 2013

Does it Take More Time to Teach Distant Learners? (No, really...)

Does teaching online take more time than teaching on campus?

For many faculty, the answer seems obvious.  But is the obvious answer correct?

I've personally come across only one research study that went beyond personal impressions.  Years ago Christine Geith and Michele Cometa did a pilot study that worked closely with nine faculty who were each experienced in teaching both campus students and also distant students.

In order to compare 'apples with apples,' each faculty member interviewed was experienced in teaching both distant learners and campus learners in comparable courses,

They began by asking each faculty member which type of teaching was more time-consuming (per student): teaching distant learners or learners on campus. Everyone agreed that teaching distant learners was more time-consuming.

But when these nine faculty each thought about it some more, most decided they'd been mistaken.

Each spent about 45 minutes estimating how much time they'd spent in each of the different activities that make up "teaching a course."

  • One third concluded they'd spent more time (per student) teaching distant learners (as they'd expected);
  • One third concluded they'd spent more time teaching campus learners; and
  • One third decided it was about the same.

From this pilot study, it appears that teaching distant learners isn't necessarily more or less time consuming than teaching students on campus. 

How can that be?

Experienced faculty can adjust elements of the course over a period of years. Eventually, 'time invested per student is more a result of time available.  (The same thing is true of university budgets, for example; the cost of teaching a student is determined by how much money over time has been available to teaching them.  I've written more about this surprising result and its implications in Ehrmann (2010).  When trying a completely new mode of teaching, a faculty member may feel compelled to invest an uncomfortable amount of time per student But after a while the workload can be tweaked until it's tolerable.

The big difference in time invested, surprisingly, was from one faculty member to another.  These nine faculty varied enormously in how much time they spent per student.  

In other words, personal preferences and circumstances have a major effect on how faculty invest their time in each student.  The mode of teaching apparently doesn't.  

*****
Ehrmann, S.C. (2010) “Improving Higher Learning by Taking the Long View: Ten Recommendations about Time, Money, Technology and Learning.”  Change Magazine, Taylor & Francis, September/October, pp. 16-22. (This article was reprinted in the January 2011 issue of Planning for Higher Education, published by the Society for College and University Planning, pp. 34-40.)


Monday, November 5, 2012

Faculty research, institutional economics, and the reward system

Some folks at research universities act as though research grants are a way for a university to make money.  Not exactly.

At universities such as George Washington, most revenue comes from student learning, either directly (tuition and fees) or indirectly (alumni gifts).

Doing research should help keep our educational programs at the cutting edge of their disciplines, and fresh. (As Ernest Boyer pointed out several kinds of research can do that. More on that below).

Research costs the university money, even grant-funded research - it must almost always be subsidized with some of those teaching-derived dollars.

So any research university walks a tightrope:

  • Divert too many of those teaching-derived dollars to non-teaching uses, and we risk our reputation as a good teaching institution (and the income we get from that reputation);
  • Divert too few teaching-derived dollars to research and our teaching could stagnate, with perhaps the same result.
I've written this down because, until recently, it wasn't obvious to me. So I thought perhaps some readers might find this useful (or worth arguing with). In either case, feel free to post a comment!

PS. Ernest Boyer, in his book Scholarship Reconsidered, described four types of scholarship, each of which, in its own way, can make teaching more vital and current:

  1. The scholarship of discovery that includes original research that advances knowledge.
  2. The scholarship of integration that type involves synthesis of information across disciplines, across topics within a discipline, or across time.
  3. The scholarship of application (also later called the scholarship of engagement) that goes beyond the service duties of a faculty to those within or outside the University and involves the rigor and application of disciplinary expertise with results that can be shared with and/or evaluated by peers.
  4. The scholarship of teaching and learning that the systematic study of teaching and learning processes. It differs from scholarly teaching in that it requires a format that will allow public sharing and the opportunity for application and evaluation by others.
We're talking more at GW about the possibilities of encouraging all four kinds of scholarship, especially (in current conversations) for associate professors building a record for promotion to full professor.